wait, have you read this?

wait, have you read this?

Share this post

wait, have you read this?
wait, have you read this?
Issue 3: Matinee Idols

Issue 3: Matinee Idols

James Bond never had to put up with this sort of shit

Maddie Coleman
Apr 09, 2021
∙ Paid

Share this post

wait, have you read this?
wait, have you read this?
Issue 3: Matinee Idols
Share

Matinee Idols

alternative title: Mr. Darcy's hand flex

📣FLRRFLRRRFLRRRNRRRR📣  Would you look at that it’s the 3rd issue of wait, have you read this? 

I want to tell you that the reason for the extended break between issues was due to a profound mix of unfounded stage fright, creative malaise, and despair over the end of a whole year of a whole pandemic and whatnot, but honestly, I downloaded TikTok in January and that’s the prime suspect of this crime. TikTok is the Vegas of apps and self-control isn’t in my personal brand’s style guide.

Friends, I have read 33 books in four months (a lot for this ol’ hag!) and about 20 of them were contemporary romance novels. Up until this year, I had at best flirted with this genre solely because I misunderstood it—I bought into the perception that it was all steamy, mass-market paperbacks devoid of anything but horny people in corsets or fairy porn. I’m here to tell you that I really played myself with my own snobbery (just like my delay to TikTok). I’ve gotten ranty before about the shame that can surround the reading experience—the devil works hard, but misogynistic marketing and the identity signifiers that books serve as work harder—so I really should have known better. Quantity is a quality of its own, and romance novels are the publishing industry’s best-selling genre for many, many reasons. 

My official introduction to this genre came through Beach Read by Emily Henry which I found via the founder of the Bad Bitch Book Club Mackenzie Newcomb’s Instagram. I could not write today’s issue without the romance novel recs from BBB so if you like the books mentioned below you should sign up—their annual romance challenge starts 4/15, what timing! Mackenzie also gave me great reading advice once to get out of a rut: read things that feel like movies or TV! And what does this bitch love more than a rom-com?

What I love most about the contemporary romance novels I’ve read, and really romance in any medium, is best explained by Helena Fitzgerald: “Love is the smallest, most selfish room. [...] Love is a day binge-watching television, going to bed instead of looking at the bad news, a warm room where we can close the door and render the real world fictional and the fictional world real. Love is pretending large things are small and small things are large.” Rom-coms and romance novels’ abilities to take something that can render us so stupid so seriously create a truly delightful form of escapism. 
 
Below you will find a selection of contemporary romance novels that got me out of reading ruts—I think these books will either introduce or reignite your love of love too. If you’re already familiar with the genre, you will see that most, if not all, of these are the enemies-to-lovers trope, and to that I will say you now know more about my psyche than I am comfortable with. 

Many of these recommendations can also be found in the most recent newsletter from Forty Winks, the world’s cutest lingerie store, which very kindly let me ramble about books to their customers. This issue’s IFYIYFs include some great selections from them because why just read a book when you can also support a women-owned small business?? Aaaand speaking of women-owned small businesses, you can grab a copy of all of this issue’s books from The Ripped Bodice. So honestly between me, BBB, and The Ripped Bodice you are going to find a romance novel you’ll love because there are so many types of romance novels—there really is a book for everyone. And if you still can’t, or if romance is too low-brow for you (boo), then I don’t know I guess you could re-watch Bridgerton for the umpteenth time unironically? No judgment! (Some judgment) (hey, are we still making Bridgerton jokes?)

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to wait, have you read this? to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Madeleine Coleman
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share